This post was contributed by a community member. The views expressed here are the author's own.

Politics & Government

Few Gains Seen In Proposed Tax On Hospitals

Lawrence & Memorial And Backus Hospitals Will Pay Millions Under New Tax.

In times of economic distress is it all right to rob Peter to pay Paul? 

Several Connecticut hospitals and legislators think that’s exactly what Gov. Dannel P. Malloy is proposing with his call for a 5.5 percent tax on nonprofit hospitals. Yet, hospitals would recover the projected $266.6 million in tax revenues, Malloy’s office counters, because by taxing and then redistributing the money, the state could get matching federal funds.
 
The tax would jump to 5.71 percent after Sept. 30, 2011. That, coupled with an $83 million cut in Uncompensated Care and DSH pool funding, could tip some hospitals over the edge, opponents of the proposal say.

“We won’t turn away anyone but it hurts an industry already on the brink of financial trouble,” said Bill Stanley, vice president of development and community relations at .

During the 2010 fiscal year Lawrence and Memorial saw just over 84,000 patients in the emergency room, less than 10 percent were self-pay. The imposition of the tax coupled with the elimination of the reimbursements will create a 2.8 million dollar loss for the hospital, Stanley said.

Backus Hospital stands to lose almost $1.5 million dollars from their operating costs if Malloy’s proposal is implemented, according to testimony submitted by David Whitehead, hospital president.

Connecticut’s hospitals employ more than 53,000 people, treat about 1.6 million in the emergency room, and admit more than 430,000 patients each year. Lawrence and Memorial employs more than 2,500 full- and part-time employees and Backus Hospital employs more than 1,700.

Both hospitals oppose the tax because of the potential negative impact on community healthcare.

“We are very concerned about what the budget will have on our region’s safety net,” said Shawn Mahwiney, a spokesperson for Backus Hospital. “The emergency department is where a lot of people end up when they don’t have health insurance.”

Backus Hospital provided more than $65 million dollars in uncompensated care and $2.8 million dollars in charity care in 2010, according to Whitehead. 

“We’re a non-profit, we have slim operating margins as it is,” Mahwiney said. “Any new tax coupled with rising uninsured people in our region...any cuts would shred the safety net in eastern Connecticut.”

“To me it’s not the best policy,” said state Sen. John McKinney, R- 28th Senate District. “We don’t know if the federal dollars will always be there and once there’s a tax increase it tends not to go away, even if it’s not needed anymore.”

Many of McKinney’s constituents go to Danbury Hospital, one of the few fiscally sound in the state. But if the tax passes, the hospital would lose about $9 million annually.

That means it must find $9 million in internal savings, said Michael Daglio, Danbury Hospital’s Senior Vice President of Operations.

As such, the hospital just started compiling a list of options, Daglio said.

First, the hospital, Danbury’s largest employer, will soon begin work on a $150 million tower. That means the hospital will start making significant interest payments, Daglio said.

“Staffing is our biggest expense and our biggest asset,” he said. “It’s a difficult thing to think about. But yes, we have to consider it. We have to think of how to get there without laying people off.”

Then there are the community clinics.

“We provide a $60 million community benefit in uncompensated care, and bad debt,” Daglio said. “The community clinics run significant money, but it’s the right thing to do.”

Stanley said Lawrence and Memorial Hospital provides $35 million dollars in education, outreach, programs and unsubsidized and charity healthcare.

Backus provided more than $5 million dollars in community outreach and health improvement initiatives on top of the money spent unsubsidized and charity health care, according to Whithead’s testimony.

Malloy’s proposed cut to the uncompensated care worries many local hospitals.

“These aren’t money-making machines,” state Rep. TR Rowe, R-123rd House District. “Many are scrambling to make ends meet. I haven’t heard one hospital who is in favor of the tax.”

“It would be a reach-back,” said Stanley of the tax that would be assessed to money earned in past years. “So, money we counted on would be affected. It has the potential to be very damaging.”

If the tax passes, many employees could lose their jobs, said Rowe.

“A number of constituents work at Yale-New Haven Hospital, St. Vincent’s Hospital, and Bridgeport Hospital. They are cafeteria workers, and pharmacists, and health care providers. The tax would affect the whole operation,” he said.

Lawrence and Memorial has approved a master facilities plan that will result in unprecedented growth, according to Stanley. The hospital is bought property for a new facility in Waterford, it’s planning to expand its clinic in Groton and is planning to build a new tower on its main campus in New London.

“If we lose $2.8 million, it’s going to make it that much harder to fund the expansion,” he said. “Construction jobs and the long-term jobs created by the new facilities would be affected.”

Stephen Frayne, the Connecticut Hospital Association’s Senior Vice President for Health Policy, called the proposal potentially devastating.

“Let’s be clear that this tax is a also a cut to hospitals – it takes $267 million from hospitals and will, as the administration asserts, ‘in the aggregate return all the money,” Frayne said. “However this assertion misses the obvious – hospital care for patients occurs locally, not in the aggregate – and when funding for services at the local level is cut, that cut hurts the ability to provide hospital care in that community."

Find out what's happening in New Londonwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

“You could argue that the hospital has helped to ease the (economic) crisis by serving the uninsured and the under-insured,” said Stanley.

If the tax passes, Connecticut would give some hospitals more money than they paid and some hospitals less than they paid. For example, while Stamford Hospital would lose about $9.5 million annually, while Norwalk Hospital would gain $1.9 million. Both Lawrence and Memorial and Backus Hospital would lose money.

"There will be some winners," said Stanley of hospitals that will gain more than they put in, "but mostly losers."

“It would be a net gainer for Norwalk Hospital,” said state Sen. Bob Duff, D-25th Senate District. “Nobody wants to impose more of a burden on hospitals, but a lot of it comes down to the overall budget and what the revenue picture looks like.”

Norwalk Hospital wouldn’t comment at this time, said Maura Romaine the hospital’s Director of Community Relations.

State Rep. Jason Perillo, a Republican who represents Shelton in the 121st House District said neither taxes nor fees are the answer. Instead, the state needs to cut government spending.

"Our non-profits are the solution, not the problem. Most specifically, the Governor's proposed hospital tax is a serious concern,” said Perillo, ranking member on the Public Health Committee. “Hospitals are our public health safety net and the proposed hospital tax will have a significant negative impact on most of them.”

The tax could also jeopardize fundraising efforts. Donors tend to shy away from ailing institutions.

In the next few weeks, Malloy will hold several more budget hearings. Meanwhile lawmakers are holding their own constituent gatherings for constituents. And it’s likely the General Assembly will go into special session to finalize the budget, said some lawmakers.

“We have a responsibility to contribute to closing the budget gap,” Danbury Hospital’s Daglio said. “But what we were hoping for was more of a dialogue.”

Find out what's happening in New Londonwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

The views expressed in this post are the author's own. Want to post on Patch?